问一个关于C++多态中析构函数调用的问题

问一个关于C++多态中析构函数调用的问题

问题描述:

在跟着B站某视频学C++学到多态时敲代码,发现一个问题,先上代码(使用的是Visual Studio)

#include<iostream>
using namespace std;
#include<string>

class cpu {
public:
    virtual void calculate() = 0;
};
class card {
public:
    virtual void display() = 0;
};
class memory {
public:
    virtual void store() = 0;
};

class IntelCPU :public cpu {
public:
    void calculate() {
        cout << "使用IntelCPU计算" << endl;
    }
    ~IntelCPU() {
        cout << "调用IntelCPU析构函数" << endl;
    }
};
class IntelCARD :public card {
public:
    void display() {
        cout << "使用IntelCARD显示" << endl;
    }
    ~IntelCARD() {
        cout << "调用IntelCARD析构函数" << endl;
    }
};
class IntelMEM :public memory {
    void store() {
        cout << "使用IntelMEM存储" << endl;
    }
};

class computer {
public:
    computer(cpu* cp, card* ca, memory* me) {
        a = cp;
        b = ca;
        c = me;
    }
    void work() {
        a->calculate();
        b->display();
        c->store();
    }
    ~computer() {
        if (a != NULL) {
            delete a;
            a = NULL;
        }
        if (b != NULL) {
            delete b;
            b = NULL;
        }
        if (c != NULL) {
            delete c;
            c = NULL;
        }
        cout << "调用computer析构函数" << endl;
    }
private:
    cpu* a;
    card* b;
    memory* c;
};

void dowork(computer* com) {
    com->work();
}
int main() {
    IntelCPU* cp= new IntelCPU;
    IntelCARD* ca = new IntelCARD;
    IntelMEM* me = new IntelMEM;
    computer* a = new computer(cp, ca, me);
    dowork(a);
    delete a;
}

结果:

img

在main函数中,delete a后cp开辟的空间确实被释放了(在computer a的析构函数中释放),但此时却没有调用IntelCPU的析构函数:

class IntelCPU :public cpu {
public:
    void calculate() {
        cout << "使用IntelCPU计算" << endl;
    }
    ~IntelCPU() {
        cout << "调用IntelCPU析构函数" << endl;
    }
};

而如果删去delete a,而加上delete cp,则会调用该析构函数:

img

但是如果同时写上:delete adelete cp,此时编译器则会报错:

img

我估计原因是因为重复释放了内存,也就证明前面cp开辟的空间确实被释放了,但此时在computer中的析构函数:

    ~computer() {
        if (a != NULL) {
            delete a;
            a = NULL;
        }
        if (b != NULL) {
            delete b;
            b = NULL;
        }
        if (c != NULL) {
            delete c;
            c = NULL;
        }
        cout << "调用computer析构函数" << endl;
    }

中的delete a(就是delete cp,,写的没注意名称重复的问题。。)却并不会调用IntelCPU的析构函数。
想问问各位对此有什么看法?
(重点不是在cp已经被释放,而是没有调用析构函数,如果我IntelCPI* cp时,cp中有指针开辟了堆上数据,那不是这部分数据就不能释放而泄漏了吗?
ps:视频中还教了一种写法,即:computer* a = new computer(new IntelCPU,new IntelCARD,new IntelMEM);,此时就完全不能调用各个Intel的析构函数了,因为在main中连类型名都没有);

你这是学的那个老是忘记STRING头文件的黑马程序员的例子吧,我也写过一个,刚才去试了下,删除computer类的时候也是没有调用intelcpu的析构函数。我也怀疑数据没有释放,但是你说----delete a后cp开辟的空间确实被释放了(在computer a的析构函数中释放),这是根据什么来的???

这是我写的代码,你试一下,也没有调用intelcpu的析构函数

#include<iostream>
using namespace std;
class CPU
{public:
    virtual void calculate()=0;
};
class intelcpu:public CPU
 {
     public:
         void calculate()
         {
             cout<<"intelcpu is working。"<<endl; 
         };
  ~intelcpu()
  {
      cout<<"intelcpu析构"<<endl;
   } 
 };
 
 
 
 
 
 class Videocard
{public:
    virtual void display()=0;
};
 class intelvideocard:public Videocard
 {
     public:
         void display()
         {
             cout<<"intelvideocard is working。"<<endl; 
         };
         
 };
 
 
 class Memory
{
public:
    virtual void storage()=0;
};
 class intelmemory:public Memory
 {
     public:
         void storage()
         {
             cout<<"intelmemory is working。"<<endl; 
         };
         
 };
 



class computer
{
    public:
        computer(CPU*cpu,Videocard*vc,Memory*mem)
        {
            mcpu=cpu;
            mvc=vc;
            mmem=mem;
        };
        void work()
    {
        mcpu->calculate();
        mvc->display();
        mmem->storage();
    };
        
    ~computer(){    if(mcpu!=NULL)
        {
        delete mcpu;
        mcpu=NULL; 
        }
        if(mvc!=NULL)
        {
        delete mvc;
        mvc=NULL; 
        }
        if(mmem!=NULL)
        {
        delete mmem;
        mmem=NULL; 
        }
        cout<<"computer析构"<<endl;
    };
    
        
        
    private:
        CPU *mcpu;
        Videocard *mvc;
        Memory *mmem;
};


 
 
 class AMDcpu:public CPU
 {
     public:
         void calculate()
         {
             cout<<"AMDcpu is working。"<<endl; 
         };
         
 };
 class AMDvideocard:public Videocard
 {
     public:
         void display()
         {
             cout<<"AMDvideocard is working。"<<endl; 
         };
         
 };
 class AMDmemory:public Memory
 {
     public:
         void storage()
         {
             cout<<"AMDmemory is working。"<<endl; 
         };
         
 };
 
 
 void test01()
 {
     CPU *cpu=new intelcpu;
     Videocard *vc=new intelvideocard;
     Memory *mem=new intelmemory;
     computer *computer1=new computer(cpu,vc,mem);
     computer1->work();
     delete computer1;
     cout<<"----------------------------------------------------------"<<endl;
     
     computer*computer2=new computer(new AMDcpu,new AMDvideocard,new AMDmemory );
     computer2->work();
     
     delete computer2;
     
 };
     
     int main()
     {
         test01();
     }